Post #139
13
This isn't even "wait, you're allowed to do that?". They've just got some nerve.
Amazon has launched an ear. But let me give you some context first.
In September, Apple unveiled the Apple Watch Series 12 and Ultra 4 with a feature set called Audio Intelligence. The headline feature is Siri Recap: the watch listens to everything around you all day and by evening produces a summary of your conversations – "to refresh your memory and keep you in the moment". Plus Live Rewind: double-press the crown and the last fifteen seconds of whatever was just said appears as text on the screen.
Apple clearly knew what they were getting into, and rolled out a whole defensive line. The feature is off by default. Raw audio is not recorded or stored. The summary is not a transcript but a compressed retelling. Speakers are not identified. Processing happens in Private Cloud Compute, which, according to Apple, even Apple itself cannot access. Summaries are deleted after seven days unless you save them. You can set a schedule: it listens at work, but not at home or at night. The launch is promised before the end of the year – for now it was just an announcement.
Ha. Didn't help. The headlines were all the same: "Apple Watch now always listening". Apple's VP John Ternus explained to journalists that the watch takes "high-level notes", not a transcript. But here's the thing: you sit down for a meeting, your colleague has Recap on their wrist – you're being recorded without your knowledge or consent. A conversation meant for the room has ended up in someone's "AI diary". At that point it doesn't matter how Apple encrypts and deletes things: the very status of the conversation has changed.
So, while Apple was busy playing defence, Amazon released two devices under the Bee brand. The Frontier bracelet at $75 and the Eclipse at $100 – a magnetic card that sticks to the back of your phone. Recording starts with a button press – Amazon makes a point of emphasising this, against the backdrop of the "always listening" Apple Watch controversy. But press it once and it records everything: conversations, meetings, someone else's remarks in the kitchen. You press the button. The people around you don't.
The audio, they say, is deleted immediately, but the transcript is kept, and AI turns it into a summary and a to-do list. And now the really interesting part – for $12 a month. With the Pro subscription, Bee connects to your Amazon account and turns offhand remarks into product recommendations. The example from the announcement itself: you say out loud that you've run out of dish soap – and it's already on your Amazon homepage. Imagine where that goes: you complain about a leaky tap and you get a plunger and a plumber. The reminders aren't the point. The point is that your day becomes a sales funnel.
We've always half-suspected we were being listened to and then shown ads. And now they want us to pay for the privilege!? Go to hell.
Okay, I'll admit it: there is a temptation. Recording a conversation with your boss or a rude shop assistant – that would sometimes be very handy. But knowing that anything I say could end up in someone's file – I wouldn't want that. In Europe this will almost certainly not be allowed – though let's see how quickly Amazon tests that.
So here's my question. Would you buy one – just for the summaries? 🐝 And if you spotted one of these on a friend's wrist, would it change how you talk to them?
Source
Amazon has launched an ear. But let me give you some context first.
In September, Apple unveiled the Apple Watch Series 12 and Ultra 4 with a feature set called Audio Intelligence. The headline feature is Siri Recap: the watch listens to everything around you all day and by evening produces a summary of your conversations – "to refresh your memory and keep you in the moment". Plus Live Rewind: double-press the crown and the last fifteen seconds of whatever was just said appears as text on the screen.
Apple clearly knew what they were getting into, and rolled out a whole defensive line. The feature is off by default. Raw audio is not recorded or stored. The summary is not a transcript but a compressed retelling. Speakers are not identified. Processing happens in Private Cloud Compute, which, according to Apple, even Apple itself cannot access. Summaries are deleted after seven days unless you save them. You can set a schedule: it listens at work, but not at home or at night. The launch is promised before the end of the year – for now it was just an announcement.
Ha. Didn't help. The headlines were all the same: "Apple Watch now always listening". Apple's VP John Ternus explained to journalists that the watch takes "high-level notes", not a transcript. But here's the thing: you sit down for a meeting, your colleague has Recap on their wrist – you're being recorded without your knowledge or consent. A conversation meant for the room has ended up in someone's "AI diary". At that point it doesn't matter how Apple encrypts and deletes things: the very status of the conversation has changed.
So, while Apple was busy playing defence, Amazon released two devices under the Bee brand. The Frontier bracelet at $75 and the Eclipse at $100 – a magnetic card that sticks to the back of your phone. Recording starts with a button press – Amazon makes a point of emphasising this, against the backdrop of the "always listening" Apple Watch controversy. But press it once and it records everything: conversations, meetings, someone else's remarks in the kitchen. You press the button. The people around you don't.
The audio, they say, is deleted immediately, but the transcript is kept, and AI turns it into a summary and a to-do list. And now the really interesting part – for $12 a month. With the Pro subscription, Bee connects to your Amazon account and turns offhand remarks into product recommendations. The example from the announcement itself: you say out loud that you've run out of dish soap – and it's already on your Amazon homepage. Imagine where that goes: you complain about a leaky tap and you get a plunger and a plumber. The reminders aren't the point. The point is that your day becomes a sales funnel.
We've always half-suspected we were being listened to and then shown ads. And now they want us to pay for the privilege!? Go to hell.
Okay, I'll admit it: there is a temptation. Recording a conversation with your boss or a rude shop assistant – that would sometimes be very handy. But knowing that anything I say could end up in someone's file – I wouldn't want that. In Europe this will almost certainly not be allowed – though let's see how quickly Amazon tests that.
So here's my question. Would you buy one – just for the summaries? 🐝 And if you spotted one of these on a friend's wrist, would it change how you talk to them?
Source